California Q2 Foreclosure Activity Lowest in Five Years

July 23, 2012

La Jolla, CA.--The number of California homes entering the formal foreclosure process dropped in the second quarter to its lowest level since early 2007. The decline stems from a combination of factors, including an improving housing market, the gradual burning off of the most egregious mortgages originated from 2005 through 2007, and the growing use of short sales, a real estate information service reported.

A total of 54,615 Notices of Default (NODs) were recorded on houses and condos during the April-though-June period. That was down 2.9 percent from 56,258 for the prior three months, and down 3.6 percent from 56,633 in second-quarter 2011, according to San Diego-based DataQuick.

Last quarter's 54,615 was the lowest since 53,943 NODs were recorded in second-quarter 2007. NODs peaked in first-quarter 2009 at 135,431. DataQuick's NOD statistics go back to 1992. The year-over-year drop was most noticeable in the Bay Area, where the 8,572 NOD filings marked a 13.4 percent drop from 9,893 a year ago.

"The foreclosure process has always been the sanitation department of the housing sector. It's where financial distress is processed. The question is whether these lower NOD numbers mean that there's less distress to process, or if we're just seeing distress get processed at a slower pace," said John Walsh, DataQuick president.

"Obviously the economy has been on the mend - however slowly. But because housing is widely seen by economists as the biggest drag on growth, some interesting alternatives to the foreclosure process are being discussed, such as the use of eminent domain to buy and restructure mortgages. Needless to say, we're all watching closely," he said.

The most active "beneficiaries" in the formal foreclosure process last quarter were Bank of America (8,299), JP Morgan (7,497), Wells Fargo (7,131), Aurora Bank (1,984) and Bank of New York (1,838).

The trustees who pursued the highest number of defaults last quarter were ReconTrust Co (mostly for Bank of America and Bank of New York), Quality Loan Service Corp (Bank of America), Cal-Western Reconveyance Corp (Wells Fargo) and NDEx West (Wells Fargo).

Most of the loans going into default are still from the 2005-2007 period. The median origination quarter for defaulted loans is still third-quarter 2006. That has been the case for three years, indicating that weak underwriting standards peaked then.

NOD filings continued to fall last quarter in communities across the home price spectrum. However, mortgage defaults remained far more concentrated in California's most affordable neighborhoods. Zip codes with second-quarter 2012 median sale prices below $200,000 collectively saw nearly 9 NODs filed for every 1,000 homes in those zip codes, while the ratio was 5.6 NODs filed per 1,000 homes for zip codes with $200,000 to $800,000 medians. For the group of zip codes with median sale prices above $800,000, there were 2.2 NODs filed per 1,000 homes.

On primary mortgages, California homeowners were a median eight months behind on their payments when the lender filed the Notice of Default. The borrowers owed a median $17,864 on a median $317,019 mortgage.

On home equity loans and lines of credit in default, borrowers owed a median $5,227 on a median $75,369 second mortgage. The amount of the credit line that was actually in use cannot be determined from public records.

San Diego-based DataQuick monitors real estate activity nationwide and provides information to consumers, educational institutions, public agencies, lending institutions, title companies and industry analysts. Notices of Default are recorded at county recorders offices and mark the first step of the formal foreclosure process.

Although 54,615 default notices were filed last quarter, they involved 53,664 homes because some borrowers were in default on multiple loans (e.g. a primary mortgage and a line of credit).

Of the state's larger counties, mortgages were least likely to go into default in San Francisco, Marin and San Mateo counties. The probability was highest in Tulare, San Joaquin and Sacramento counties.

Trustees Deeds recorded (TDs), or the finalized loss of a home to the formal foreclosure process, totaled 21,851 during the second quarter. That was down 27.8 percent from 30,261 for the prior quarter, and down 48.5 percent from 42,465 for second-quarter 2011.

Last quarter's Trustees Deeds total was the lowest for any quarter since the second quarter of 2007, when 17,458 were filed.

The all-time peak for Trustees Deeds was 79,511 in third-quarter 2008. The state's all-time low was 637 in the second quarter of 2005, DataQuick reported.

Just as with NOD filings, Trustees Deeds, or foreclosures, remained far more concentrated in the state's most affordable neighborhoods. Zip codes with second-quarter 2012 median sale prices below $200,000 collectively saw 4.3 homes foreclosed on for every 1,000 homes in existence. That compares with 1.9 foreclosures per 1,000 homes for zip codes with medians between $200,000 and $800,000, and less than one - 0.5 - foreclosure per 1,000 homes in the group of zip codes with $800,000-plus medians.

While 1.45 million of California's roughly 8.7 million houses and condos have been involved in a foreclosure proceeding the past five years, 835,000 went through the whole foreclosure process. The other 615,000 were either sold, or the payments were brought current.

Foreclosure resales accounted for 27.9 percent of all California resale activity last quarter, down from a revised 33.6 percent the prior quarter and 35.6 percent a year ago. It peaked at 57.8 percent in the first quarter of 2009. Foreclosure resales varied significantly by county last quarter, from 7.3 percent in San Francisco County to 47.4 percent in Madera County.

Short sales - transactions where the sale price fell short of what was owed on the property - made up an estimated 18.0 percent of statewide resale activity last quarter. That was down from an estimated 20.1 percent the prior quarter and up from 17.4 percent a year earlier. In terms of the number of short sales, last quarter's estimated 20,141 was up 13.0 percent from the prior quarter and up 10.2 percent from a year earlier.

On average, homes foreclosed on last quarter took 7.7 months to wind their way through the formal foreclosure process, beginning with an NOD. That's down from an average of 8.5 months the prior quarter and down from 10.0 months a year earlier.

At formal foreclosure auctions held statewide last quarter, an estimated 40.1 percent of the foreclosed properties were bought by investors or others who don't appear to be lender or government entities. That was up from an estimated 33.4 percent the previous quarter and up from 28.3 percent a year earlier, DataQuick reported.

Notices of Default (Trustees Deeds further down)
houses and condos

County/Region              2011Q2        2012Q2        Yr/Yr%
       
Los Angeles                11,250        10,568         -6.1%
Orange                       3,705         3,599         -2.9%
San Diego                    4,158         4,099         -1.4%
Riverside                    5,534         5,677          2.6%
San Bernardino               4,334         4,487          3.5%
Ventura                      1,133         1,152          1.7%
Imperial                       270           250         -7.4%
Socal                      30,384        29,832         -1.8%
       
San Francisco                  402           295        -26.6%
Alameda                      2,030         1,789        -11.9%
Contra Costa                 2,552         2,214        -13.2%
Santa Clara                  1,793         1,474        -17.8%
San Mateo                      732           613        -16.3%
Marin                          279           220        -21.1%
Solano                       1,185         1,137         -4.1%
Sonoma                         738           680         -7.9%
Napa                           182           150        -17.6%
Bay Area                     9,893         8,572        -13.4%
       
Santa Cruz                     245           258          5.3%
Santa Barbara                  487           442         -9.2%
San Luis Obispo                345           313         -9.3%
Monterey                       489           443         -9.4%
Coast                       1,566         1,456         -7.0%
       
Sacramento                   3,397         3,202         -5.7%
San Joaquin                  1,675         1,580         -5.7%
Placer                         849           788         -7.2%
Kern                         1,485         1,508          1.5%
Fresno                       1,612         1,637          1.6%
Madera                         284           279         -1.8%
Merced                         510           483         -5.3%
Tulare                         714           831         16.4%
Yolo                           201           222         10.4%
El Dorado                      377           289        -23.3%
Stanislaus                   1,094         1,133          3.6%
Kings                          184           230         25.0%
San Benito                      85           105         23.5%
Yuba                           195           157        -19.5%
Colusa                          35            44         25.7%
Sutter                         217           175        -19.4%
Central Valley             12,914        12,663         -1.9%
       
Mountains*                     635           648          2.0%
       
North Calif*                 1,241         1,444         16.4%
       
Statewide*                 56,633        54,615         -3.6%

 includes additional counties

Trustees Deeds Recorded (number of homes foreclosed on)
houses and condos

County/Region              2011Q2      2012Q2     Yr/Yr%
       
Los Angeles                 6,733        3,553       -47.2%
Orange                      1,887        1,052       -44.3%
San Diego                   2,763        1,391       -49.7%
Riverside                   4,810        2,395       -50.2%
San Bernardino              4,083        2,012       -50.7%
Ventura                       697          360       -48.4%
Imperial                      274          147       -46.4%
Socal                      21,247       10,910       -48.7%
       
San Francisco                 156          103       -34.0%
Alameda                     1,317          638       -51.6%
Contra Costa                1,799          900       -50.0%
Santa Clara                   991          392       -60.4%
San Mateo                     328          182       -44.5%
Marin                         130           74       -43.1%
Solano                        916          475       -48.1%
Sonoma                        495          258       -47.9%
Napa                          129           61       -52.7%
Bay Area                    6,261        3,083       -50.8%
       
Santa Cruz                    191           84       -56.0%
Santa Barbara                 319          185       -42.0%
San Luis Obispo               270          107       -60.4%
Monterey                      425          167       -60.7%
Coast                       1,205          543       -54.9%
       
Sacramento                  3,160        1,562       -50.6%
San Joaquin                 1,399          729       -47.9%
Placer                        641          320       -50.1%
Kern                        1,555          802       -48.4%
Fresno                      1,392          780       -44.0%
Madera                        298          151       -49.3%
Merced                        585          230       -60.7%
Tulare                        607          408       -32.8%
Yolo                          231          110       -52.4%
El Dorado                     393          149       -62.1%
Stanislaus                  1,199          533       -55.5%
Kings                         157          118       -24.8%
San Benito                     73           47       -35.6%
Yuba                          184           91       -50.5%
Colusa                         40           17       -57.5%
Sutter                        160          113       -29.4%
Central Valley             12,074        6,160       -49.0%
       
Mountains*                    525          358       -31.8%
       
North Calif*                1,153          797       -30.9%
       
Statewide*                 42,465       21,851       -48.5%

* includes additional counties

Source: DataQuick; DQNews.com

Media calls: Andrew LePage (916) 456-7157

Copyright 2012 DataQuick. All rights reserved.